Is Victoria different?

Less than a fortnight now to the Victorian state election, Australia’s biggest electoral event for this year. With Labor having been in office for twelve years there’s an almost universal expectation that the voters will opt for change and make opposition leader Jess Wilson the new premier. But there’s still some doubt as to whether her Liberal Party, either alone or in conjunction with the Nationals, can win a majority or will have to rely on the far-right party, One Nation.

The surge in One Nation support has been the big story this year in Australia. For about the first half of the year it was clearly a nationwide story. Opinion polls showed the party gaining ground across the board, and it won convincing victories in by-elections in two very different locations: Farrer in regional New South Wales and the state seat of Secret Harbour in suburban Western Australia. Most impressive of all, it collected 22.9% in March in the state election in South Australia, outvoting the Liberals by four points in what is generally seen as a fairly progressive state.

But more recently, doubts have set in. One Nation’s poll numbers have plateaued, and a range of pundits have suggested that they are in line to win no more than a handful of seats – perhaps none at all – in Victoria’s lower house. Meanwhile, Labor’s fortunes have continued to nosedive, with July’s leadership change from Jacinta Allan to Ben Carroll having failed to improve its standing. The more seats Labor loses, the easier it will be for the Coalition to compile a majority without having to worry about One Nation.

Liberals and Nationals go into the election with respectively twenty and nine of the 88 seats; they need to win, net, another 16 for a majority. On the basis of a uniform swing that requires a swing of 7.6%, with Monbulk as the median seat. The polls have them doing considerably better than that, with a swing in the neighborhood of 10%, but that takes no account of the risk of One Nation either cannibalising their own seats or getting ahead of them in the seats they need to win from Labor.

The punters have very little doubt: Sportsbet’s odds this afternoon show a Coalition majority government as the overwhelmingly favored option at six to one on. A Coalition minority government – the most likely outcome if One Nation holds the balance of power – is at five to one against, while a minority Labor government is at 16-1. The far right’s bid for office is not being taken very seriously, with odds of 20-1 against “any other party” providing the next premier; that’s blown out from 15-2 in late August.

But the markets for individual seats tell a slightly different story. If each seat was won by its current favorite, the totals would come out as Liberal 38, Nationals nine, Labor 26, One Nation nine, Greens five and one (Morwell) tied between Nationals and One Nation. That’s still a Coalition majority, but it’s a much more respectable One Nation tally than the overall market (and much of the commentary) would lead you to believe.

Moreover, apart from Morwell the prospective One Nation gains are all in Labor seats: there is no National-held seat in which One Nation is outright favorite. I confess I find this difficult to believe; if One Nation does well enough to pick up more than one or two Labor-held seats, I think it will clean up in the bush. But many pundits (from whom the punters are perhaps taking their cue) are obsessed with the idea of the far right as a predominately outer suburban phenomenon.

In any case, we’ll know soon enough. Stoking fears of a One Nation government does not seem to have helped Labor so far, although there is still time for it to claw back some ground. For the opposition, overconfidence is probably a more serious problem, plus the danger that by recommending preferences to One Nation it has again given permission to its voters to jump ship. But we’ll have another look at that next week, together with some more thoughts on the other parties.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.